8 Florida Amish Pie Spots Baking Their Way Into Local Legend

Florida’s pie scene is as sweet and rich as its sunshine and nowhere is that more evident than at the state’s beloved Amish bakeries and pie shops. From Gulf Coast towns to inland hidden gems, these spots have become go‑to destinations for locals and visitors who chase creamy, fruity, and perfectly baked pies.

Many of these pie destinations have roots in Florida’s unique Amish and Mennonite communities, particularly in places like Pinecraft, where gatherings, village bakeries, and homestyle cooking create pie traditions that draw crowds year‑round. These pies aren’t just desserts, they’re pieces of local lore that reflect decades of baking expertise.

Across the state, these pie spots offer everything from classic fruit fillings and custard pies to Key lime twists and seasonal specials. Whether you’re planning a pie‑centered day trip or just want to taste local legend, these bakeries are essential stops for every Florida pie lover.

1. Yoder’s Amish Village & Restaurant (Sarasota)

Yoder’s Amish Village & Restaurant in Sarasota is a must-visit for anyone craving authentic Amish pies and homestyle cooking. The moment you walk in, the sweet aroma of baked pies and fresh bread fills the air, giving a sense of warmth and comfort that feels like a home away from home.

The menu is anchored by their famous pies, ranging from classic fruit-filled favorites to creamy custards and seasonal specials. Each slice is generous and rich with flavor, making it perfect for enjoying after a long day exploring Sarasota or following a scenic drive through Florida’s Amish country.

The atmosphere is casual and inviting, with friendly staff and a bustling dining room that reflects the popularity of the place. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick slice or sitting down for a full meal, Yoder’s delivers the kind of flavors that keep locals and visitors coming back year after year.

yodersrestaurant.com
(941) 955-7771
3434 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34239

2. Der Dutchman (Pinecraft, Sarasota)

Der Dutchman in Pinecraft, Sarasota, is a charming spot where Amish baking traditions meet hearty, homestyle meals. The restaurant is known for its welcoming atmosphere, with the scent of fresh pies, breads, and home-cooked meals greeting guests as soon as they arrive.

Their pies are the highlight, from classic fruit fillings to rich custards and seasonal specialties. Each slice is generous and carefully prepared, offering a taste of authentic Amish baking that pairs perfectly with their breakfast and lunch menu items.

The vibe is cozy and lively, reflecting both the local community and visiting food lovers. Whether stopping in for a quick treat or a full meal, Der Dutchman provides a satisfying experience that’s rooted in decades of culinary tradition.

derdutchman.com
(941) 955-8007
3713 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34232

3. New River Groves (Davie)

New River Groves in Davie is a family-friendly spot known for its fresh, Florida-inspired pies and sweet treats. The moment you step inside, the aroma of baked fruit pies and citrus delights fills the air, setting the tone for a warm and inviting visit.

The pies here highlight the state’s produce, featuring flavors like key lime, mango, and classic berry combinations. Each pie is crafted with care, offering a balance of sweet and tangy flavors that make it a standout stop for dessert lovers and visitors exploring the area.

The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, with a market-style setting where guests can also browse fresh produce and local goodies. It’s the kind of place where families, friends, and food enthusiasts come together for a sweet taste of Florida tradition.

newrivergroves.com
(954) 581-8630
5660 Griffin Rd, Davie, FL 33314, United States

4. Yoder’s Pie Craft Coffee Co. (Sarasota)

Yoder’s Pie Craft Coffee Co. is a cozy Sarasota spot that combines the comfort of Amish pies with expertly crafted coffee. The moment you walk in, the smell of freshly baked pies mingles with roasted coffee beans, creating an inviting and warm atmosphere.

The menu features a range of pies, from classic fruit fillings to creamy custards, paired perfectly with espresso drinks, lattes, and cold brews. Each slice is generous and made with care, offering a sweet treat that’s perfect for a mid-morning break or afternoon indulgence.

The vibe is relaxed and welcoming, with casual seating and friendly staff who make every visit feel personal. Whether stopping by for coffee, a slice of pie, or both, Yoder’s Pie Craft Coffee Co. delivers a comforting, flavorful experience.

yoderspiecoffeeco.com
(941) 556-7684
3404 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34232

5. Heavenly Honey Amish Warehouse (Lake Alfred)

Heavenly Honey Amish Warehouse in Lake Alfred has become a beloved stop for Amish foods, baked goods, and specialties that feel like a taste of old‑fashioned goodness. It’s known for shelves stocked with jams, jellies, preserves, raw honey, and other classic Amish pantry items that make excellent souvenirs or gifts.

While this spot isn’t a traditional bakery focused solely on pies, its selection often includes Amish‑made baked treats alongside their sweet spreads and local honey. Visitors enjoy browsing through unique goods, discovering artisanal flavors, and sampling classic products that capture the spirit of Amish craftsmanship.

The atmosphere is friendly and welcoming with a community feel, making it more than just a quick stop, it’s a place to linger, explore, and take home a bit of Florida’s Amish food culture. Whether you’re picking up pie accoutrements or local honey, it offers a warm, memorable visit.

300 S Lake Shore Way, Lake Alfred, FL 33850
(863) 547‑7276

6. The Amish Country Store & Bakery (Largo)

The Amish Country Store in Largo might not be a traditional bakery, but it’s a beloved foodie destination for anyone chasing authentic Amish pies and baked goods in Florida. Long known as a local favorite, this spot feels like stepping into a classic country market where everything is laid out to be savored slowly, from jams to pies and pantry staples.

Here you can find a variety of Amish‑style baked treats alongside other authentic goods that reflect classic homestyle flavors. While the selection isn’t limited to pies, the sweet, flaky pastries and fruit pies often draw visitors who are specifically seeking that nostalgic taste of Americana.

The atmosphere is friendly and inviting, a no‑rush kind of place where browsing feels as delightful as sampling. It makes a great stop for food lovers exploring Florida’s pie culture and looking to bring home something sweet that reflects the local Amish baking tradition.

amishcountrystore.com
(727) 587‑9657
206 13th St SW, Largo, FL 33770

7. Ken’s Amish Deli & Bakery (Mount Dora)

Ken’s Amish Deli & Bakery in Mount Dora feels like finding a sweet old‑fashioned gem tucked off the main road. The moment you see the Amish buggy signage and walk onto the porch seating, it sets the tone for a visit that’s as much about community as it is about food.

This spot is loved for baked treats that feel handcrafted, with pies, turnovers, and pastries often made fresh each week. Locals especially look forward to Friday creampuffs , light, fluffy, and perfectly sweet, alongside classic deli fare like hearty sandwiches and fresh breads that pair beautifully with a slice of pie.

The atmosphere is relaxed and friendly, with a covered outdoor seating area that makes it feel more like a friendly neighborhood gathering than a typical bakery stop. Here, browsing Amish preserves, jams, and specialty grocery items adds another layer of charm to the experience.

kensamishmarket.com
(888) 399‑5002
335 S Highland St, Mount Dora, FL 32757

8. Yoder’s of Pinecraft Gift Shop

Yoder’s of Pinecraft Gift Shop is a charming addition to the well‑loved Amish Village in Sarasota, where the focus goes beyond just pies to include homemade goods and traditional Amish specialties. The moment you step in, shelves stocked with jams, jellies, preserves, and artisanal pantry items make it clear this place is about good food and meaningful gifts.

This shop is especially popular with visitors who want to bring a piece of Florida’s Amish‑inspired baking culture home. Alongside sweet spreads and locally produced honey, you’ll find items that complement the pies from the restaurant and bakery next door, making this a great place to combine shopping with a dessert run.

The atmosphere is warm, casual, and welcoming, with a relaxed vibe that encourages browsing and tasting. It feels like strolling through a local market where every product has a story and every purchase makes a tasty memory.

(941) 366‑3208
3434 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34239

The post 8 Florida Amish Pie Spots Baking Their Way Into Local Legend first appeared on Beyond the Bayou Blog.