Halloween Mummy Meatballs That Make You Smile

Sharing is caring!

Why I Love These Mummy Meatballs More Than Anything This Season

There’s a chaos to making these that I secretly adore — the way the shredded cheese eyes melt into the meat, like tiny, squinty ghosts peeking out. It’s messy, it’s playful, and honestly, it pulls me out of the usual dinner rut. I find myself giggling at how absurdly cute they turn out, especially when I toss a few extra “bandages” of cheese on top.

Plus, these meatballs bring back childhood memories of Halloween nights filled with candy and costumes, but with a grown-up twist. They’re perfect for when you want something familiar but a little unexpected — like a cozy, edible costume party. Making them always feels like a small act of rebellion, turning simple ingredients into something a little spooky and a lot fun.

What I Love About the Ingredients (And Why They Matter)

• Ground beef: I lean toward 80/20 for juiciness. Skip it if you want leaner, but don’t expect as much flavor or bite.
• Breadcrumbs: I use day-old sourdough for a richer crumb. Swap for gluten-free if needed, but stick to something slightly hearty.
• Garlic and onion: They make the meat sing. If you’re out of fresh, a good pinch of garlic powder works fine, but fresh is best for aroma.
• Cheddar or mozzarella: The oozy eyes add charm. Use what melts well and has a mild flavor—no sharp cheeses here.
• Tomato sauce: I like a smoky, slightly spicy sauce to contrast the richness. Skip if you prefer plain gravy, but it needs that punch.
• Shredded cheese for bandages: I go with mozzarella for stretchiness, but a mild provolone can add a different bite.
• Olive oil or baking spray: For crisping, it’s simple but essential. Don’t skip the oil or they tend to stick and steam instead of crisp.

Step-by-Step for Crafting Your Creepy Little Cuties

Equipment & Tools

• Large mixing bowl – to combine everything easily.
• Baking sheet with parchment – for easy cleanup and even browning.
• Small cookie scoop – to make uniform meatballs.
• Sharp knife – for shaping cheese “bandages.”
• Oven thermometer – if you don’t trust your oven’s temp.

Steps

1. Preheat your oven to 200°C (400°F). Line your baking sheet with parchment.
2. Mix ground beef, breadcrumbs, minced garlic, chopped onion, salt, and pepper in the bowl. Don’t overmix—just combine until it’s uniform.
3. Use the cookie scoop to form meatballs about 2 inches wide. Place them evenly spaced on the sheet.
4. Bake for 20-25 minutes, until they’re golden and just cooked through. They should jiggle slightly but not be raw inside.
5. While they bake, chop your cheese into thin strips—these become your “bandages.”
6. Once out of the oven, let the meatballs rest for 5 minutes. Then carefully wrap cheese strips around each, leaving tiny gaps for eyes.
7. Place small cheese dots or olives for eyes. Return to oven for 2-3 minutes, just until the cheese melts and eyes soften.
8. Heat your tomato sauce on the stove, simmering gently until fragrant, about 10 minutes.
9. Serve the meatballs in a shallow dish with the sauce poured over or on the side. The cheese should be gooey, and the meat juicy.

How to Know It’s Done

• Meatballs reach 75°C (165°F) internally—juicy but fully cooked.
• The cheese bandages are melted and slightly browned.
• The outside is crisp, with a bit of crackle when you bite in.

Mistakes and Fixes That Keep You Smiling

• FORGOT to preheat the oven? Crank it up now and give the meatballs a few extra minutes to brown.
• DUMPED too much cheese? Wipe off excess, so it doesn’t burn or drip into the oven—less mess, more fun.
• OVER-TORCHED cheese? Cover lightly with foil and lower the heat slightly for a few minutes.
• MEATBALLS too dense? Mix just until combined, don’t overwork the meat.

Quick Kitchen Fixes for Spooky Mishaps

• When cheese isn’t melting well, splash a tiny bit of milk or broth on top and bake for another minute.
• When sauce is too thick, stir in a splash of water or broth—watch the shimmer return.
• Spray your baking sheet with extra oil if meatballs stick—no one wants a sad, broken pile.
• When the meat mixture feels dry, fold in a tablespoon of milk or beaten egg to keep things moist.
• If the cheese eyes crack or fall off, patch with a dab of melted cheese and a quick bake—five seconds of rescue magic.

Making these mummies isn’t just about the end look — it’s about enjoying the little chaos of shaping and filling your kitchen with warm smells of garlic and melted cheese. They’re a reminder that Halloween is about having fun, even if things get a little messy.

These meatballs are perfect for a casual party, a cozy weekend, or just because you want to see a smile spread across someone’s face. The best part? You can tweak the fillings, sauces, and cheese types to make it uniquely yours. No matter what, they’ll always bring a little spooky joy to the table.

Sometimes, the simplest ingredients come together in the most unexpected ways. These mummies aren’t just a snack—they’re a little ritual that makes any evening feel special. So, get your hands dirty, enjoy the chaos, and watch the faces light up when you set these creepy, cheesy bites down.